‘Wicked: For Good’ or for worse?
After waiting an entire year for “Wicked: For Good” to come out, since Nov. 21, it is finally out on the big screen. Since last year’s release of “Wicked,” fans have had high hopes for “Wicked: For Good” due to how well the first movie adapted the first act of the musical on screen. However, the continuation of the second act shouldn’t have been two hours.
As “Wicked” is based on the Broadway musical by the same name, the musical itself is well-known and loved, for good reason, too. Similar to a modern-day classic, the belts hit people to their core, and the acting is top-tier, making the audience feel like they’re right there in Oz. The movie gave similar emotional impacts to just of the acting did in the musical. As the wonderful “Wicked” world gave plenty of beautiful, clever storytelling to break down, it also gave its fair share of flaws.
The reason why “Wicked: For Good” wasn’t perceived as well as the first movie was because of its lack of consistency. With the movie’s pacing, it’s no surprise that it felt rushed towards the end, especially when the second act of the musical is similarly rushed, with only an hour to finish the story. Even though there were extra scenes added to make the movie not feel as rushed, there are still so many plot holes left behind that leave viewers puzzled.
Many of these plot holes are due to there being such a bigger focus on the two main characters: Elphaba and Glinda. There were many issues from Act One that were barely mentioned or presented in Act Two. One example is the animal situation in Oz. In the musical, the animal situation was still a side plot, but had more relevance to the story than it does in the movie.
The animal plot isn’t the only plotline nearly abandoned by the movie. There’s also a lack of interactions and screen time for side characters like Boq as the Tin-Man, Fiyero as the Scarecrow, and the lion cub as the Cowardly Lion. Their own personal arcs of being transformed with magic didn’t have enough time to develop after each incident. They get transformed and then randomly show up towards the end of the movie with feelings of either hatred or love towards Elphaba.
However, the movie does have some amazing aspects. The lighting, for one, is gorgeous in every scene. It reflects the emotions of the characters and the moods of the scenes incredibly well. It points the audience’s attention to the right areas and is effective in getting points across.
The costuming was also incredibly well-made, especially with Glinda’s wardrobe. Her blue dress she wears for the majority of the movie not only represents her inner change of authority and rule in Oz, but the dress also acts as a nod to the original musical. Although Glinda wears a pink dress in the original 1939 “The Wizard of Oz” movie, the Broadway musical initially featured a blue one instead.
For the Tin-Man’s costume, Ethan Slater almost looks unrecognizable. But for the close-up, ending scene with the Scarecrow and Elphaba, it makes Jonathan Bailey look like Ryan Reynolds.
Another huge aspect of this film is the soundtrack. In “Wicked”, the incorporation of songs from the original musical plays a crucial role in the storytelling. The overall impact of each number depends not only on the vocal performances but also on how seamlessly the music is integrated into the narrative and emotional structure of the film.
After the first “Wicked” movie came out, Broadway composer Stephen Schwartz announced that there would be two new additional songs added to the second movie that are not a part of the original Broadway production: “No Place Like Home” and “Girl in the Bubble.” These two songs reflect Elphaba and Glinda’s characters, adding depth to who they truly are as individuals.
Additionally, there have been minor changes from the musical to the film, such as Glinda being added into the song “Wonderful” and “Girl in the Bubble” interrupting half of “March of the Witch Hunters.”
However, not every soundtrack is perfect, as each song holds its own flaws, especially when some changes weren’t as necessary as others.
This song title refers to the scene near the end of “The Wizard of Oz” where the main character, Dorothy, clicks her heels to get back to her home in Kansas, saying, “There is no place like home.”
In Elphaba’s case, she reflects on her love for Oz, the place she calls home, although she doesn’t receive the same love back.
For many viewers, hearing this song serves as a relevant reminder about the current political climate of our country and other countries, and how they aren’t being recognized as “home” by all the changes that have occurred. Through the lyrics of “When you feel you can’t fight anymore / Just tell yourself / There’s no place like home” and “Oz belongs to you too,” they are able to connect with audiences who are feeling the same way as Elphaba.
Schwartz confirmed in an interview with NBC News that this song was inspired by the feeling of loving a place you call home, even if there is negativity and hate from within. This then allows viewers to understand the sacrifice that Elphaba makes at the end of the movie.
The only drawback from this scene is the interruption by the Cowardly Lion just as Elphaba is about to sing the final high note from the song. Many viewers found this frustrating when considering Cynthia Erivo’s vocal ability and the emotional weight of the moment. The interruption also shifts in the tone, redirecting the scene toward the Lion’s attempt to spread fear among the other animals.
In the musical, this song is sung by the Wizard alone, but in “Wicked: For Good”, Glinda is added to sing along with the Wizard. This is a great depiction of the complex relationship Glinda, the Wizard, and Elphaba have: with the Wizard using a complicit Glinda as a manipulation tool to get Elphaba to join his cruel plan for Oz’s future.
Meanwhile, this addition reveals a more complex view of Glinda as a character. At this point between the two movies, Glinda is fully aware of the injustice the current system has done to Elphaba. Yet, she continues to join in, convincing her to join the exact system that hurt her.
Adding this auditory and visual complexity to the song deepens the understanding of the characters’ motives. A splendid choice for this song overall.
There were high expectations for this song, mainly because of Slater’s role as Boq, who turns into the Tin-Man. With his previous experience on Broadway as SpongeBob, there was concern about how his portrayal was going to play out towards Elphaba and wanting to get rid of her.
He did not disappoint in his performance.
Slater absolutely embodies this role as he yells the lyric: “I have a personal score to settle with the witch!” He ultimately transformed the Tin-Man into a resentful and even scarier man to see on screen, particularly with the glare that he gives Glinda. Not to mention, the vocals of the mob of Witch Hunters absolutely helped carry the song. But one part that was missed from the musical was the beginning line: “Good fortune, Witch Hunters!” Ultimately, this song did not deserve to be cut off by “Girl in the Bubble.”
This song appears when Glinda receives a bubble transportation machine from the Wizard to mask her lack of magic. However, the lyrics point to a much deeper understanding of her character.
Glinda’s love for magic, at this point, has faded away, and she has desperately wanted to become the spotlight by having powers and true magic within. This is seen through the flashback where Glinda got a bubble wand for her birthday. After attempting magic and getting questioned by her peers, she lied and said she made a rainbow appear. Really, she never made any magic at all.
This song is about Glinda breaking down and saying that her so-called picture-perfect life is full of lies. It gives a much-needed reminder to the audience that Glinda’s character isn’t just the naive, bubbly, preppy girl. She’s all too aware of her situation and where she’s ended up in life, at the cost of her closest friend. Not only is she aware, but she’s also grieving the direction her life went.
This is when her awareness explicitly shifts from being blissfully complicit with the Wizard to apprehension of being the figurehead they want.
“For Good” stands out as one of the most emotionally devastating songs in the entire musical. The emotions that are sung throughout the entire line land with full force as Glinda and Elphaba share their final moments for the very last time before Elphaba sacrifices herself and is presumed “dead.” The improvisation of both of them saying “I love you” to each other adds to the bittersweet feeling, showing how deep their connection had become from when they first met at Shiz.
This is a song many people were looking forward to since the announcement of the second movie last year, and there weren’t many concerns about it compared to the rest of the film. It was definitely a tearjerker meant to get you misty-eyed with reflection, and it does its job incredibly well, leading to the ending finale.
It is especially impactful to the audience because of how simple and quiet the moment is compared to the other songs in this film. Without any flashy visuals, the focus stays on Glinda and Elphaba’s emotions and the meaning of their saying their goodbyes to each other. This beautiful song emphasizes growth and acceptance. It shows that even though they must go their separate ways, their friendship has permanently changed both of them, making the moment both heartbreaking and truly unforgettable.
Although the overall movie may not have fully met fans’ highest expectations, its cinematography and emotional passion create a bittersweet atmosphere that signals the end of a beloved era.
Whether for better or for worse, “Wicked: For Good” offers audiences a fresh and thoughtful interpretation of classic moments that are cherished by many. It ultimately leaves the audience reflecting on the story long after the credits start rolling, highlighting the emotional power behind its characters and themes.
The film’s ability to spark conversation proves its impact, even amidst the mixed reactions. “Wicked: For Good” succeeds in ending the story in a way that feels meaningful and memorable.
No matter if you enjoyed the movie in its entirety or captured many of its flaws, one thing stands clear: this is a film that truly got many people talking and raised the standards of cinematography for good.




▸ Rude or obscene language (i.e. swear words, sexual jokes, violent threats, etc.)
▸ Hate speech (i.e. racism, sexism, homophobia, etc.)
▸ Insults towards a specific student or a teacher
▸ Content that is irrelevant to the article or does not add to the discussion
▸ Submitting comments under somebody else's name
Refer to the student handbook for further specifics on what is considered appropriate.
The Social Media Editor will read and evaluate all comments. Should there be any issues with a particular comment, the Social Media Editor will consult the newspaper adviser and Online Editor-in-Chief.